Turbo Squid
Turbo SquidProductsSearchShopping CartMemberForumsCompanySupport
Forum: Posts From:
bgreg
Poster
32 Posts
Lightwave v Viz
Posted 19-Oct-2005 5:56 AM

Whats the + and - of each package .... I have a basic understanding of Viz/Max but Iam looking to do some serious training and want to know what avenue would be the best to persue. I would be using the program mainly for Architectural Visualizations... Thanks for any comments you might have....

Cheers G

RayMoe
New Poster
1 Post
9 Products
RE: Lightwave v Viz
Posted 19-Mar-2006 1:41 PM
Modified by RayMoe On 19-Mar-2006  1:43 PM

Hi there,

     Autodesk VIz formerly known as LightScape? First of all, I have no expirience with VIZ. What I can tell you is this. LightWave 3D is a highly professional Software. A little bit complex but professional. It's lightning and rendering techniques are so good that nobody needs an external renderer. As long as you know to use LightWave you will be very happy with it. Although there is one point you don't have to forget. VIZ is specialized in Lightning, Radiosity and Global Illumination. That's the point which makes it very worthfull, even for LightWave users. The possibilities that you have, for modifying your Lightning setup are immense and powerful. Generally it would be wrong to ignore this Software completely. As a LightWave user, or whatever Software you are happy with. The only lack is the price. Nearly 3000,00 € are not a small amount of money. Everyone has to decide hinself.

bye,
   RayMoe
Hystoria
Advanced Poster
1457 Posts
85 Products
RE: Lightwave v Viz
Posted 22-Mar-2006 9:51 AM

For architectural work, I would definitely go with Viz over LightWave. Lightwave has NO architectural tools whatsoever, no stairs, no moulding presets, no doors, no windows. You have to build your walls in pieces, or boolean out holes for doors and windows. Alignments are not precise. It doesn't support .dwg or any CAD imports (although there is a new $200 simple CAD plug-in you can buy for the soon-to-be-released version 9). After building several houses as props for one of my clients this past winter, I can tell you for sure that architectural work in LW is FAR too time-consuming and imprecise.

Viz interfaces well with AutoCAD and 3dsMax because they are all Autodesk products, and knowledge of Viz is likely to make you more employable in your chosen field. Many architects use Autodesk products; only a few use LightWave. I am buying Max this spring primarily so I can interface with my architectural-product clients better, despite having used LW for more than 3 years and being comfortable with its toolset.

On the plus side for LightWave, the application is far less expensive, and the out-of-the-box renderer produces nicer results. I think Viz still uses the Lightscape renderer, which I--personally--don't particularly like. OTOH, if you're pursuing further education, the cost of educational SW (Viz, for example), is quite reasonable, and you can later upgrade your license to the full commercial version.

LightWave's real strengths are in organic modeling and any form of illustration not requiring exact precision. It also has good animation tools. It's a great piece of software, but not one I would recommend for someone primarily interested in architectural visualization.

Hystoria
Advanced Poster
1457 Posts
85 Products
RE: Lightwave v Viz
Posted 22-Mar-2006 10:19 AM

Ug, I just noticed this... RayMoe, you woke up a dead thread, originally posted in 10/05. This person is probably long gone, or has already made a decision on sw use. Please check dates before responding to topics; it's pointless to respond to threads more than (at MOST) a month old.
ioe
New Poster
1 Post
RE: Lightwave v Viz
Posted 31-Oct-2006 3:10 AM

SG227
Poster
46 Posts
4 Products
RE: Lightwave v Viz
Posted 08-Mar-2007 5:56 PM

I have to agree with joe
bgreg
Poster
32 Posts
RE: Lightwave v Viz
Posted 09-Mar-2007 3:08 AM

Nope still watching the forums .... so no reply is ever wasted....
jburford
New Poster
3 Posts
2 Products
RE: Lightwave v Viz
Posted 27-Jan-2008 3:56 AM

Actually Lightwave CAD (LWCAD) is tightly integrated with Lightwave and version 1.5 was given to lots of LW purchasers of 8.x or 9.x...  It gives the complete Toolset for Archviz as well as presets for moulding and such..  It is hot.
Items per page